What is menu engineering?
Menu engineering rates every item on two measures: how well it sells against the rest of the menu, and what each sale leaves after ingredients. The two measures sort the menu into four groups, each with its own next step. Michael Kasavana and Donald Smith set out the method in 1982.
How does the calculator sort your menu?
- Contribution margin = price before VAT − cost per item. It's what each sale leaves to pay for staff, rent and profit.
- Sales mix = the item's number sold ÷ all items sold.
- Popularity line = 70% × (1 ÷ number of items). On a menu of 10 items an equal share is 10%, so the line is 7%. An item that reaches it is popular.
- Average contribution = total contribution ÷ all items sold. An item that reaches it is profitable.
Food cost % (cost ÷ price before VAT) shows beside each item, but it doesn't set the class. A sandwich at 34% can leave more dirhams per sale than a latte at 14%. The class goes by the dirhams, not the percentage.
A worked example with two items
From the invented menu above: 10 items and 10,000 sold in a month, so the popularity line is 7.0%. The total contribution is AED 152,973.70 over 10,000 items, so the average is 15.30. Amounts in AED.
| Step | Croissant | Pour-over |
|---|---|---|
| Price with VAT | 14.00 | 25.00 |
| Price before VAT (÷ 1.05) | 13.33 | 23.81 |
| Cost per item | 5.00 | 2.71 |
| Contribution each | 8.33 | 21.10 |
| Sold | 1,200 | 270 |
| Sales mix (÷ 10,000) | 12.0% | 2.7% |
| Popular? (line 7.0%) | Yes | No |
| Profitable? (average 15.30) | No | Yes |
| Total contribution | 9,996.00 | 5,697.00 |
| Class | Plowhorse | Puzzle |
The croissant sells more than four times as many as the pour-over. But each pour-over leaves about two and a half times as much.
AED 1 more on the croissant (0.95 before VAT) adds 1,140 a month at the same sales. The pour-over needs about 463 more cups a month to reach the line, and would then add 9,769.30.
What should you do with each class?
- Stars: popular and profitable. Keep the recipe and portion steady, and give them the best places on the menu and the board. Test any price rise in small steps.
- Plowhorses: popular, but low margin. Raise the price a little, cut the cost (portion, packaging, supplier price), or pair them with a high-margin add-on. Go slowly on drinks whose price your regulars know.
- Puzzles: profitable, but few people order them. Move them up the menu, put them on the board, have the team suggest them, or give them a better name and description. If sales don't move in a few weeks, treat them as weak items.
- Weak items: neither popular nor profitable. Rework the recipe or the price, or take them off and give the space to a Star or a new item.
What does the method leave out?
Menu engineering looks at ingredients and sales only, so read the result with what you know of your café:
- Labour and prep time. A sandwich that takes four minutes to make can leave more per sale than a latte made in one. It can still earn less per hour of work.
- Fixed costs. Rent and salaries don't change with each sale. Contribution is what pays for them, so it isn't net profit.
- What an item brings with it. A pastry that sells beside a coffee, or a drink people come in for, can be worth more than its own row says.
- The lines move. Both are averages of this menu, so adding or removing one item shifts every class. When drinks and food sell very differently, compare drinks with drinks and food with food. Use an ordinary period, away from Ramadan and holiday rushes, unless you're planning for one.
To cost an item line by line before you enter it, use the food cost and menu price calculator. For pricing, read how to price a coffee menu. The VAT calculator takes VAT out of any price.
In Seyaqi, the numbers this calculator asks for are already there. Each product's cost comes from its recipe, at the average cost your bills keep up to date. Till sales arrive line by line on the day they happened: hourly from Foodics and Shopify, or from Sapaad's day sheet.
Each product shows what it leaves you. When a supplier's price rise reaches your products, the AI Advisor tells you which ones. Seyaqi runs this today in cafés and roasteries, including the Roasteries edition.
General information as of November 2026, not tax advice. The calculator takes 5% VAT out of each price. A business must register for VAT once its taxable supplies and imports pass AED 375,000 over 12 months. If yours isn't registered, its prices carry no VAT, so untick the box. Official sources: the Federal Tax Authority on VAT and on registration.